On American
Innovation
The Chinese Sputnik
Gal Luft
San Francisco Chronicle
Sunday, October 7, 2007
Fifty years ago, America panicked upon learning of the Soviet Union's
launch of the Sputnik. The Communist spacecraft orbiting the Earth was a stern
wake-up call, shaking the collective sense of American invincibility and
bringing Americans to realize that they were no longer the masters of missile
and space technology. Indeed, it was a national humiliation: The Russians are
ahead of us. We are behind. As historian Michael Beschloss said, Sputnik was
"the first big moment of national self-doubt after World War II." Today, with
plummeting currency, heavily in debt, deadlocked in Iraq and facing growing
international antipathy, we are at a new moment of self doubt, unaware that
another Sputnik is in the making. This time the surprise, also coming from a
Communist country, will not be in the sky but on the ground. Our next Sputnik is
the Chinese automobile soon to roll onto America's roads.
With an economy growing at a sustained rate of 10 percent a year and
millions of Chinese with growing disposable income now abandoning their bicycles
in favor of family cars, China's auto market is growing by leaps and bounds.
China is already the world's third-largest car market and it is projected to
overtake Japan by 2010. Not long after that it is likely to pass the United
States.
Exhibiting the same hubris that our leaders showed 50 years ago, American
automakers still believe that the quality and appeal of their products will
defend them against China. To be sure, China still has a way to go before it can
produce cars of quality comparable to that of the Big Three. But the quality gap
is closing rapidly. China trains four times more engineers than the United
States while systematically violating patent laws and replicating technologies.
The Chinese allow foreign automakers to operate in their country only through
joint ventures with domestic manufacturers. This allows them to learn new
manufacturing techniques and to gradually improve the appeal of their products.
Chinese cars like Geely and Chery that until recently failed to pass the strict
U.S. safety and environmental standards now are close to doing so. It could take
as little as a decade for China's auto industry to become competitive with
Western manufacturers. Once this happens, ailing Detroit could be on the
ropes.
China auto industry's cost advantage enables it to commercialize the
gasoline-sipping, no-compromise cars that consumers desire. Due to the low cost
of their basic platform - a Chinese full-size family sedan could sell for as
little as $10,000 - Chinese automakers will be able to add fuel choice and
advanced vehicle technologies that Detroit is slow to adopt because of the extra
cost involved. Take, for example, plug-in hybrid electric vehicles that allow
motorists a 20-to-40 mile drive on grid electricity stored in an on-board
battery, after which the car lapses into a normal hybrid driving mode. The main
barrier to their market penetration is a cost differential of some $12,000
compared with today's gasoline engine cars. Such a cost difference is a problem
for American manufacturers. But for the Chinese, adding a plug-in capability
would still keep the sticker price lower than that of a non-hybrid U.S. made
car. A car capable of achieving over 100 miles per gallon of gasoline, and a per
mile cost saving of 80 percent, at the price of a gasoline-only car could be
China's Sputnik - and it's coming soon to the showroom near you.
Fifty years ago, it was the space race that determined America's
security and posture in the world. Today, it is the race for energy resources.
The Sputnik anniversary is a reminder that our technological superiority is
facing constant challenge and without proper investment in technological
education, innovation and research and development, our edge will forever be
eroded. But the Sputnik experience also had a silver lining. It unleashed an
unprecedented boost of investment in science and engineering education and
research. It brought to the creation of the Defense Advanced Research Projects
Agency (DARPA), NASA and scores of other government programs designed to restore
America's technological superiority. Commanding space and closing the missile
gap became top national priorities. Twelve years later, Neil Armstrong took his
first steps on the Moon.
China is now on track to provide our auto and energy sectors with what
the Soviets provided our weapons and space industries - a jolt. If a Chinese
Sputnik is what's needed to awaken Detroit and Congress to boost investment and
speed up the commercialization of vehicles that run on clean and cheap
nonpetroleum fuels, then so be it.
Gal Luft is executive director of the Institute for the Analysis of
Global Security (IAGS), a Washington, D.C., energy policy think tank, and
co-founder of the Set America Free Coalition.